tailscalealternatives.com A guide by Firezone

Seven Tailscale alternatives, sorted by design

The alternatives to Tailscale are not seven copies of one product. They have three different designs, and the design decides which one fits your team. Firezone publishes this guide, and Firezone is one of the seven.

See how Firezone comparesBook a demo

Three designs for private accessThree rows show three designs. In a mesh, two devices connect directly to each other. With a gateway, a client reaches a private app through a gateway in the same network. With a cloud proxy, a client reaches a private app through the network of a vendor.Mesh: device to deviceGateway: person to resourceCloud proxy: through the network of a vendorLaptopServerruns the clientDirect tunnelno hop betweenLaptopGatewayin your networkPrivate appno softwareLaptopVendor networkcan inspect trafficPrivate appbehind a connector
  1. Mesh

    Each device runs the client and connects directly to each other device. Tailscale, Headscale, NetBird, and ZeroTier use this design.

  2. Gateway

    A gateway in your network carries traffic to hosts that run no software. Firezone and Twingate use this design.

  3. Cloud proxy

    Traffic goes through the network of the vendor, which can inspect it. Cloudflare Zero Trust uses this design.

The three designs behind the alternatives

Each of the Tailscale alternatives uses one of three designs. Select the design first, and then select the product.

Mesh

Each device runs a client, and each device connects directly to the others. A mesh is a good fit for a group of devices that must all reach each other. To reach a host that cannot run the client, one device routes traffic for a subnet.

Gateway

People connect to resources, not to devices. A gateway in each network carries traffic to the hosts behind it, and those hosts run no software. Rules name a group of people and a resource. This design is the usual meaning of zero trust network access.

Cloud proxy

Traffic goes from the device to the network of the vendor, and then to your app. The vendor can filter and inspect the traffic. The cost is that the vendor is in the path of each connection.

The seven alternatives

Firezone

Firezone is open source zero trust access built on WireGuard. It uses the gateway design. A new account permits nothing, and each Policy opens one Resource for one Group. Firezone hosts the control plane, and you run the Gateways. For access between devices, Device Pools connect two Clients directly.

Good fit: a company that gives each team access to its own apps. Poor fit: a team that must host the control plane itself, because Firezone does not support that setup.

NetBird

NetBird is an open source mesh VPN built on WireGuard. You can use the hosted service, or you can host the full product yourself.

Good fit: a team that wants a mesh and wants to host all of it. Poor fit: a team that does not want to operate more infrastructure.

Headscale

Headscale is an open source control server that the community maintains. It works with the Tailscale clients, and you host it yourself. It is the nearest thing to a self-hosted Tailscale alternative that keeps the same clients.

Good fit: a homelab, or a small team that has the skills to operate it. Poor fit: a company that needs a vendor to support the product.

Twingate

Twingate is a commercial zero trust access product. It uses the gateway design, with connectors in each network. It is not open source, and it does not use WireGuard.

Good fit: a company that wants access for each resource and does not need open source. Poor fit: a team that wants to read the code.

ZeroTier

ZeroTier makes virtual networks at layer 2, with its own protocol. Devices on one virtual network behave as if they are on one Ethernet switch.

Good fit: software that needs layer 2, for example a protocol that uses broadcast. Poor fit: a team that wants WireGuard.

Cloudflare Zero Trust

Cloudflare Zero Trust uses the cloud proxy design. Traffic goes through the Cloudflare network.

Good fit: a team that already uses Cloudflare, or a team that needs access to web apps from a browser with no client. Poor fit: a team that does not want a vendor in the path of its traffic.

Plain WireGuard

WireGuard is free, fast, and in the Linux kernel. You get a tunnel and no more. You move keys by hand, you write each peer into a configuration file, and you open a UDP port.

Good fit: two or three servers that do not change. Poor fit: a team with people who come and go.

Find the alternative that fits

Answer three questions to get a place to start. The answer is a suggestion, not a ranking.

Do you want to host the control plane yourself?

What do you connect most of the time?

Can you install a client on each device?

Start with Headscale or NetBird

These two projects are open source, and you can host the full product yourself. Headscale keeps the Tailscale clients. NetBird has its own clients. Plan for the time that you must spend to operate and upgrade the control plane.

Stay with a mesh VPN

A mesh is the correct design for traffic between devices. Tailscale and NetBird are the usual choices. If you also want rules that deny by default, look at Firezone Device Pools.

Start with Firezone

You give people access to company systems, and you can install a client. That is the gateway design. Firezone is open source and is built on WireGuard, and a new account permits nothing until you add a Policy. Follow the quickstart to try it.

Look at a cloud proxy

Access from a browser with no client is the job of a proxy for web apps. Cloudflare Zero Trust is one product of that type. Firezone needs a Client on the device, so it is not the correct tool for this case.

What to compare before you select one

  • The default. Find out if a new network permits all connections or no connections. The default is the state that you have when a person forgets a rule.
  • The unit of a rule. A rule can name a device, a subnet, a port, or one DNS name. Smaller units give more precise access.
  • The path of your traffic. Find out if traffic goes directly between your endpoints, or through the network of the vendor.
  • The source code. Find out which parts are open source: the client, the gateway, or the control plane.
  • Hosts with no client. Printers, databases, and old servers cannot run a client. Find out what carries their traffic.
  • Failure. Find out what occurs when a gateway stops, and when the control plane stops.
  • The work to operate it. A product that you host yourself costs time for each upgrade and each incident.

Where Firezone is different

Firezone has three properties that few of the alternatives have together.

  • Closed by default. A user can reach a Resource only after a Policy joins a Group to that Resource.
  • Rules for a DNS name. Each DNS Resource gets its own address on the device, so two apps on one server can have two different Policies.
  • Open source and WireGuard. The Clients, the Gateway, and the control plane are open source, and all traffic uses WireGuard.

Firezone also balances load between the Gateways in a Site, and a Client moves to a different Gateway when one stops. Traffic goes directly between the Client and your Gateway. Firezone relays carry it only when a direct path is not possible, and Firezone cannot decrypt it.

Tailscale alternatives, side by side

This table shows the design of each product. Tailscale is in the first column for reference.

TailscaleHeadscaleNetBirdTwingateFirezone
DesignMeshMeshMeshGatewayGateway, and a mesh with Device Pools
Uses WireGuardYesYesWith Tailscale clientsYesNoYes
Open sourcePartialThe core of the clientYesYesNoYes
Hosted control planeYesNoYou host itYesYesYes
Support for a control plane that you hostNoPartialFrom the communityYesNoNo
Hosts with no clientSubnet routerSubnet routerPeer that routesConnectorGateway
A new network permitsAll devicesAll devicesAll devicesNo accessNo access

Firezone made this table from the public documentation of each product on 2026-11-20. Products change. Read the documentation of each product before you decide.

Common questions

What is the best open source Tailscale alternative?

That depends on the design that you want. For a mesh that you host yourself, look at NetBird and Headscale. For access to company systems that is closed by default, look at Firezone. All three are open source.

Is there a self-hosted Tailscale alternative?

Yes. Headscale is a control server that you host, and it works with the Tailscale clients. NetBird can also run fully on your own servers. The Firezone code is open source, but Firezone does not give documentation or support for a control plane that you host. With Firezone, you run the Gateways and Firezone runs the control plane.

Which alternatives use WireGuard?

Firezone, NetBird, and Headscale use WireGuard. Twingate and ZeroTier use their own protocols.

Is plain WireGuard sufficient?

Plain WireGuard is sufficient for a small number of servers that do not change. It has no sign-in, no groups, and no automatic exchange of keys. Each of the products in this guide adds those things on top of a tunnel.

Can I try an alternative while I keep Tailscale?

Yes, in most cases. Two products can run on one device when they route to different addresses. Move one system, make sure that it works, and then move the next system.

Try the alternative that starts closed

Firezone is open source zero trust access built on WireGuard. You run the Gateways, and Firezone runs the control plane. The Starter plan is free.

See plans and pricingBook a demo